• Zur Metanavigation
  • Zur Hauptnavigation
  • Zur Suche
  • Zum Inhalt
  • Zur Subnavigation
  • Zum Seitenfuß
  • University of Hamburg
  • For journalists
  • Staff Service Portal0
  • STiNE
https://www.kus.uni-hamburg.de/aktuelles.json?recentnews=true
  • Institutions and target groups
    • Einrichtungen
      • Faculties

        • Faculty of Law
        • Faculty of Business, Economics and Social Sciences
        • Faculty of Medicine
        • Faculty of Education
        • Faculty of Humanities
        • Faculty of Mathematics, Informatics and Natural Sciences
        • Faculty of Psychology and Human Movement Science
        • University of Hamburg Business School
      • Services

        • Study Information Net STiNE
        • Surfmail
        • Exchange
        • Staff Service Portal
        • Learning Platforms
        • Katalogplus – Catalogue of Hamburg Libraries
        • SharePoint
      • Student facilities and services

        • Campus Center
        • Career Center
        • PIASTA
        • AStA (student council)
        • University Sports
        • University Music
        • Family Office
        • University Language Center
        • General Languages
        • Office of Affairs for Students with Disabilities or Chronic Diseases
        • Departmental libraries
        • Healthy Campus
      • Further facilities and services

        • The Cluster of Excellence CLICCS
        • The Cluster of Excellence CUI
        • The Cluster of Excellence Quantum Universe
        • The Cluster of Excellence Understanding Written Artefacts
        • Hamburg Research Academy
        • Pier Plus
        • Hamburg Center for University Teaching and Learning (HUL)
        • Hub for Crossdisciplinary Learning (HCL)
        • CEN
        • Museums and collections
        • University Archives (in German)
        • Regional Computing Center (RRZ)
        • University Administration
        • Knowledge Exchange Agency
        • The Unikontor Shop (in German)
    • Target groups

      • Prospective students
      • Students
      • International prospective students
      • Young researchers
      • Researchers
      • Instructors
      • Staff
      • Prospective continuing education students
      • Alumni
      • Journalists
      • Refugees (in German only)
    Close
  • /sitemap.json
University of Hamburg - to research, to teach, to educate and form, to homepage

CSMC

CSMCCentre for the Study of Manuscript Cultures
  • About
    • People
    • News
    • Ethics
    • Equity & Diversity
    • Sustainability
    • Logbook: The CSMC Blog
    • Contact & Newsletter
    • Vacant Positions
    • Intranet
  • Research
    • Concepts & Methods Units
    • Project Groups
    • Individual Research Projects
    • Working Groups
    • Affiliated Projects
    • Fellowships
    • Research Events
    • UWA I (2019–2025)
    • SFB (2012–2020)
  • Core Units
    • Laboratories
    • Graduate School
    • Cultural Heritage
    • Library
  • Collaboration
    • with Research Partners
    • with Archives, Libraries, and Museums
    • with Artists
    • with Companies
    • with Schools
    • within the HALM and PIER Networks
  • Publications
    • manuscript cultures
    • Studies in Manuscript Cultures
    • Occasional Papers
    • Software
    • Research Data and Information Systems
    • Written Artefact Profiling Guide
    • Artefact of the Month
    • Mesopotamian Bulletins
    • Videos
    • More Publications

Photo: UHH/Denstorf

  1. UHH
  2. CSMC
  3. About
  4. Logbook: The CSMC Blog
  5. Ethics and Artefacts

Ethics and Artefacts

16 January 2023

Researchers, especially if they work with cultural heritage objects, often face situations that require their moral rather than their scientific judgement. Cécile Michel explains how the Ethics Working Group and Committee can provide help – and when researchers have to take responsibility themselves

Lesen Sie hier die deutsche Version dieses Artikels.

Cécile Michel presenting a few clay tablets. In this case, there is no doubt about their provenance – she made them herself.

Cécile Michel is familiar with this by now. She regularly receives requests from people who own one of the objects she knows so much about: Mesopotamian cuneiform tablets. Could she not be so kind as to translate the text? The curiosity, one may assume, goes both ways: the owners naturally want to know what document from the distant past has come into their hands. A business contract? A personal letter? And for Michel, who has devoted much of her career to ancient Mesopotamian culture, such written artefacts are the most important sources.

Nevertheless, she declines many of these requests. The reason is that she often gets an alarming response to her first enquiry: how did you come by this clay tablet? ‘Often they say that they recently bought it on Ebay. In fact, many such objects are offered for sale there. And not infrequently they are stolen goods’, says Michel.

*

Unfortunately, not everyone appreciates cuneiform tablets for their cultural significance or their value for research. During the last decades – especially in the aftermath of the Gulf Wars, the civil wars in Syria and Libya, and the advance of the so-called ‘Islamic State’ – countless objects were looted and sold for significant amounts of money. In some cases, this black market for antiquities helps funding terrorist organisations. Eventually, many of the pieces end up in the hands of private individuals who are often unaware of these sinister circumstances. For this reason, Michel argues, researchers are obliged to educate people and make buyers of antiquities realise that their actions are problematic. She herself does not want to take any scientific advantage of illegally traded objects, and neither researches nor publishes on unprovenanced clay tablets.

In the last 20 years, the trade in looted antiquities has flourished. Researchers must take a stance.

 

For some years now, researchers – especially in archaeology, but also in many other disciplines – have been struggling with the question of how to deal with artefacts of suspicious or undocumented origin. On the one hand, there is the potential knowledge that research into these objects might yield; knowledge that, due to the uniqueness of the pieces, cannot be acquired any other way. To obtain this knowledge, however, researchers must incur the risk of making themselves complicit with a market that benefits, of all people, those who pose one of the greatest threats to the preservation of cultural heritage today: looters and terrorists like the followers of ‘ISIS’.

For a long time, there was little awareness of this potential dilemma within the scientific community. People did research on whatever material was available without asking many questions about the whereabouts. Over the last 20 years, in which the trade in looted antiquities has flourished, this nonchalant attitude has become inviable. In response, various researchers and scientific institutions have adopted a very restrictive attitude. In 2004, for example, the Archaeological Institute of America (AIA) announced that its American Journal of Archaeology would no longer publish articles on unprovenanced objects acquired after 30 December 1970. On that day, the UN General Assembly adopted the 'Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property' – the first time that standards for the acquisition of cultural property were formulated at the international level. In the scientific community, the view that unprovenanced objects should no longer be used for research became predominant then. In some cases, serious moral accusations were levelled against anyone who did not subscribe to this view.

The backlash followed soon. The renowned archaeologist and Assyriologist David I. Owen, for instance, equated measures such as those of the AIA with censorship and lamented the enormous loss of knowledge that would result from refusing to publish research on unprovenanced objects. The primary task of scientists, according to this line of argument, is to record, preserve, and disseminate knowledge. Nobody would be helped if valuable objects and the information they contain were to disappear into private collections.

In sum, the debate has all the characteristics that are typical of moral disputes: a complex subject matter, strong opinions, and deep disagreement.

What matters is that we raise awareness among as many colleagues as possible that our work has an ethical dimension.

Under these circumstances, it is important not to leave alone researchers who want to act ethically but cannot assess all relevant aspects themselves, but to provide them with guidelines. At CSMC, this is precisely what the Ethics Working Group, which is chaired by Cécile Michel, is meant to do. In late 2022, the group published its recommendations on ‘Ethical and Responsible Research at CSMC’, which they had been working on intensely for over a year. While also including recommendations on how to deal with unprovenanced objects, the guide attempts to do justice to the far more diverse requirements facing researchers who deal with cultural heritage objects. Among other things, these also regard the correct behaviour in countries with very different legal systems and social norms, the acknowledgement of hidden workers, public appearances, and importantly also the treatment of research data.

Made up of scholars and scientists from different disciplines, the aim of the Ethics Working Group and the guidelines it has published is not to patronise researchers or give them clearly defined instructions for action. Rather, it is intended to make them aware of the complex ethical dimension of their work and to support them in making responsible decisions. While acting within the laws, Cécile Michel emphasises, the final judgement is always incumbent upon the respective researcher.

In addition to the Ethics Working Group, CSMC has also established an Ethics Committee, which is much smaller – besides Cécile Michel, it consists of the linguist Jost Gippert and the computer scientist Ralf Möller. Its task is to give advice to members of CSMC in specific cases. Unlike the working group, which meets regularly, the committee only meets upon request. Since its inauguration, it has been consulted five times so far. The committee then tries to gather as many relevant facts as possible and makes a recommendation. In most cases, the questions concerned the prevalent issue of written artefacts of dubious origin.

*

While Cécile Michel has decided not to work with unprovenanced objects, she knows too well how complicated each individual case can be. Therefore, she does not judge any colleague who decides otherwise. ‘It is important to realise that there can be good arguments both for and against publication. It would be hypocritical to condemn everyone who decides to publish because once the publications are out, everyone works with them. What matters is that we raise awareness among as many colleagues as possible that our work has an ethical dimension.’ Every researcher, especially when dealing with cultural heritage objects, should at least be able to ask the right questions. It remains an intricate task, one that cannot be taken away from the individual, to find the right answers.

Latest articles

Writing in colour

Photo: Hill Museum & Manuscript Library

18.11.2026|Logbook: The CSMC Blog
‘Colour cannot be interpreted in isolation from its cultural setting’
Everyone who writes does so in a particular colour. What symbolic and practical reasons drive the choice of certain colours, and how do these choices differ across cultures? Archaeometrist Olivier Bonnerot and classical archaeologist Christof Berns are leading a new project group on this topic.
From left to right: Narmeen Idrees, Kaja Harter-Uibopuu, Sandro Tskhvedadze, Amir Mahdi Moslehi, and Benedetta Giammugnai, Reading the City Summer Academy in Istanbul, September 2026.

Photo: Rafi Çiçek

20.10.2026|Logbook: The CSMC Blog
Reading Inscribed History
Spanning architectural and cultural layers from antiquity to the present, the city of Istanbul preserves a rich record of inscriptions. During a recent Summer Academy in Istanbul, doctoral researchers from the CSMC explored these epigraphic sources on site. In this report, they share their...

Last update: 2 October 2025

  • Feedback
  • Legal notice
  • Privacy statement
  • Accessibility
  • Site map

University of Hamburg

Innovating and Cooperating for a Sustainable Future in a Digital Age

  • Follow us on Instagram.
  • Follow us on Facebook.
  • Connect with us on LinkedIn.
  • Follow us on Mastodon.
  • Follow us on Bluesky.
  • Subscribe to our channel on YouTube.
    • Studies
    • Prospective students
    • Continuing education
    • Research
    • Teaching at UHH
    • Doctoral studies
    • Job opportunities
    • Knowledge exchange
    • University
    • Excellence
    • Faculties
    • Alumni
    • Contact
    • Campus Navigator
    • UHHApp
    • Emergencies, safety and security
    • Antidiscrimination
Go to family-friendly higher education institution audit
Go to internationalisation re-audit
Go to the Sustainability Audit page
Go to Diversity Audit
Go to System accreditation

© 2026 University of Hamburg. All rights reserved