• Zur Metanavigation
  • Zur Hauptnavigation
  • Zur Suche
  • Zum Inhalt
  • Zur Subnavigation
  • Zum Seitenfuß
  • University of Hamburg
  • For journalists
  • Staff Service Portal0
  • STiNE
https://www.kus.uni-hamburg.de/aktuelles.json?recentnews=true
  • Institutions and target groups
    • Einrichtungen
      • Faculties

        • Faculty of Law
        • Faculty of Business, Economics and Social Sciences
        • Faculty of Medicine
        • Faculty of Education
        • Faculty of Humanities
        • Faculty of Mathematics, Informatics and Natural Sciences
        • Faculty of Psychology and Human Movement Science
        • University of Hamburg Business School
      • Services

        • Study Information Net STiNE
        • Surfmail
        • Exchange
        • Staff Service Portal
        • Learning Platforms
        • Katalogplus – Catalogue of Hamburg Libraries
        • SharePoint
      • Student facilities and services

        • Campus Center
        • Career Center
        • PIASTA
        • AStA (student council)
        • University Sports
        • University Music
        • Family Office
        • University Language Center
        • General Languages
        • Office of Affairs for Students with Disabilities or Chronic Diseases
        • Departmental libraries
        • Healthy Campus
      • Further facilities and services

        • The Cluster of Excellence CLICCS
        • The Cluster of Excellence CUI
        • The Cluster of Excellence Quantum Universe
        • The Cluster of Excellence Understanding Written Artefacts
        • Hamburg Research Academy
        • Pier Plus
        • Hamburg Center for University Teaching and Learning (HUL)
        • Hub for Crossdisciplinary Learning (HCL)
        • CEN
        • Museums and collections
        • University Archives (in German)
        • Regional Computing Center (RRZ)
        • University Administration
        • Knowledge Exchange Agency
        • The Unikontor Shop (in German)
    • Target groups

      • Prospective students
      • Students
      • International prospective students
      • Young researchers
      • Researchers
      • Instructors
      • Staff
      • Prospective continuing education students
      • Alumni
      • Journalists
      • Refugees (in German only)
    Close
  • /sitemap.json
University of Hamburg - to research, to teach, to educate and form, to homepage

Written Artefact Profiling Guide

WRITTEN ARTEFACTPROFILING GUIDE
  • Questions
    • What is my Written Artefact made of?
    • How does my WA change through time?
    • Where does my WA come from?
    • Can the damaged or hidden writing be made visible again?
    • How can different writing initiatives be distinguished?
    • How to date my WA?
    • How to prove my WA is not a forgery?
    • Can material analysis help the preservation and conservation of my WA?
    • How can I study my WA if I only have digital images?
    • How can my paleographical analysis be corroborated?
  • Artefacts
  • Materials
    • Writing Substances
    • Writing Surfaces
  • Methods & Equipment
    • Microscopy
    • Imaging
    • VIS-NIR Spectrophotometry
    • X-Ray Diffraction
    • X-Ray Emission Spectrometry
    • Vibrational Spectroscopies
    • Mass Spectrometry
    • Omics-Analysis
    • Computational Approaches
    • Analysis of Physical Properties
  • Case Studies
  • Back to CSMC

Photo: CSMC

  1. UHH
  2. CSMC
  3. Written Artefact Profiling Guide
  4. Questions
  5. How can my paleographical analysis be corroborated?

How can my paleographical analysis be corroborated?

Handwriting Analysis

Olivier Bonnerot, Hussein Adnan Mohammed

Scholars working with manuscripts often have to decide whether two handwritten pages (or even whole codices) were written by one and the same person. The identity of the scribe responsible for copying a manuscript or a large section of it may be known in many instances, but this is not always the case. Determining the identity of particular hands allows us to establish when the undated manuscript was written, how it should be contextualised and whether or not it is an autograph.

We developed a state-of-the-art learning-free pattern classification method for the task of automatic handwriting style analysis in images of written artefacts. The main goal of this computational method is to analyse handwritten documents (or manuscripts) in order to measure the similarities between different handwriting styles as demonstrated in H. Mohammed, V. Märgner and H. S. Stiehl, "Writer Identification for Historical Manuscripts: Analysis and Optimisation of a Classifier as an Easy-to-Use Tool for Scholars from the Humanities,". These similarity measurements can be used, for example, to provide supporting information for the scholars related to the task of scribe identification. More information can be found here.

Material analysis can also be a useful complement to paleographic analysis. The investigation of the ink composition of different parts of a manuscript can in some cases provide further evidence for differentiating different hands, or different writing sessions, or assigning different parts of a manuscript to specific scribes. Such analysis is mostly successful when dealing with iron-gall ink, which contains a number of metallic elements (Fe, Cu, Zn, Pb etc…) in varying/different proportions, allowing reliable comparison and discrimination of ink compositions. The interpretation of the results however, has to be done in cooperation between the material scientists and paleographers (for example, several scribes may share the same ink and tools on a manuscript, leading to an identical ink composition despite different hands; the opposite, with different ink compositions but one hand can also happen, if a manuscript was written in different sessions).

More

Case Studies

  • Erfurt Manuscripts
  • Comparing Arabic handwriting styles using conventional and computational methods

References

  • El-Khatib, A. (2023), ‘Editing MSS Leiden Or. 14.545 b–c: The oldest Qurʾān fragments in Leiden University Library’, Journal of Islamic Manuscripts, 14/2–4: 235–278 <https://doi.org/10.1163/1878464X-01401004>.
  • Blezer, H. W. A. (2023), ‘Towards a definition of local orthographies of Bon manuscripts: A pilot study’, in A. Helman-Ważny and C. Ramble (eds), Bon and Naxi Manuscripts, Berlin/Boston: De Gruyter, 1–21 <https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110776478-008>.
  • Heiles, M. (2021), ‘Johannes Hartlieb: Leben und Werk vor 1441. Zugleich ein Beitrag zur Schreiberidentifizierung’, Zeitschrift für deutsches Alterum und deutsche Literatur, 150/3: 337–379 <https://doi.org/10.3813/zfda-2021-0012>.
  • Ciotti, G. and M. Franceschini (forthcoming 2024), ‘Experimenting with digital palaeography: The first application of the Handwriting Software Tool (HAT 3.5) to Indian scripts’, in A. Cuna and F. Freschi (eds), The Universe of Knowledge: Celebrating Shiyali Ramamrita Ranganathan (1892–1972), Udine: Tracce Area Umanistica e della Formazione.
  • Mohammed, H. and A. Helman-Ważny (2022), ‘Understanding the Zhangzhung Nyengyu tsakali collection using computational pattern analysis’, CEUR-WS, 3301: 2.
  • Mohammed, H., V. Märgner and T. Seidensticker (2020), ‘A comparison of Arabic handwriting-style analysis using conventional and computational methods’, manuscript cultures, 15: 77–86.
  • H. Mohammed, V. Märgner and H. S. Stiehl (2018), ‘Writer identification for historical manuscripts: Analysis and optimisation of a classifier as an easy-to-use tool for scholars from the humanities’, in 16th International Conference on Frontiers in Handwriting Recognition (ICFHR), Niagara Falls, NY, USA, IEEE, 534–539 <https://doi.org/10.1109/ICFHR-2018.2018.00099>. 
  • Mohammed, H., V. Märgner, T. Konidaris and H. S. Stiehl (2017), ‘Normalised local Näive Bayes Nearest-Neighbour classifier for offline writer identification’, 2017 14th IAPR International Conference on Document Analysis and Recognition (ICDAR) <https://doi.org/10.1109/ICDAR.2017.168>. 

Research Questions

  • What is my Written Artefact made of?
  • How does my WA change through time?
  • Where does my WA come from?
  • Can the damaged or hidden writing be made visible again?
  • How can different writing initiatives be distinguished?
  • How to date my WA?
  • How to prove my WA is not a forgery?
  • Can material analysis help the preservation and conservation of my WA?
  • How can I study my WA if I only have digital images?

Last update: 8 October 2026

  • Feedback
  • Legal notice
  • Privacy statement
  • Accessibility
  • Site map

University of Hamburg

Innovating and Cooperating for a Sustainable Future in a Digital Age

  • Follow us on Instagram.
  • Follow us on Facebook.
  • Connect with us on LinkedIn.
  • Follow us on Mastodon.
  • Follow us on Bluesky.
  • Subscribe to our channel on YouTube.
    • Studies
    • Prospective students
    • Continuing education
    • Research
    • Teaching at UHH
    • Doctoral studies
    • Job opportunities
    • Knowledge exchange
    • University
    • Excellence
    • Faculties
    • Alumni
    • Contact
    • Campus Navigator
    • UHHApp
    • Emergencies, safety and security
    • Antidiscrimination
Go to family-friendly higher education institution audit
Go to internationalisation re-audit
Go to the Sustainability Audit page
Go to Diversity Audit
Go to System accreditation

© 2026 University of Hamburg. All rights reserved